© 2005 George Spitz for Council, georgespitz.com

Marathon Miracle

Famed race had humble beginning

By John Jeansonne
Newsday
Friday November 1, 1996

Photo by Jay Brady
George Spitz, left, had the idea for a five-borough marathon and Abe Beame was the mayor who gave the okay.

  Invention is the mother of an eventual necessity to explain. Just how could anyone have believed, 20 years ago, in the possibility of running a 26-mile, 385-yard footrace through the streets of New York City's five boroughs?
  "Why did I think it would work?" repeated George Spitz, widely credited with the five-borough idea, "Because Ted Corbitt said it would work. He told me it was technically feasible."
  And why did Corbitt, himself a veteran of 199 marathon races, think it was feasible? "Actually, they pulled off a miracle," he said. Up until then, the New York City Marathon had been run entirely within Central Park, with four repeated loops.
  Corbitt, now a 76-year-old retired physical therapist who intends to walk this year's marathon on Sunday, offered to send himself on daily runs through Brooklyn and Queens in early 1976, scouting the "least traffic- laden areas." With the aid of fellow runner Harry Murphy -- "Harry had a car," Corbitt said -- and his own bicycle equiped with "old instruments to measure the course," Corbitt helped map out a couple of possible routes.
  Marathon maestro Fred Lebow, cocreator of the race when it debuted in the park in 1970, persuadcd two-time Olympic medalist Frank Shorter to run New York in '76, in a sort of five-borough showdown with America's other big-name marathoncr. Bill Rodgers. Hardly convinced that such an ambitious project would work, Shorter said that he "just wanted to show up and see how the police would clear the streets. That alone would be an accomplishment."
  Two thousand and eighty-nine others showed up with Shorter --almost four times the number who had participated in the park the year before. One thousand, five hundred and forty-nine finished. Somehow, they reinvented the wheel that day,
  "It's a mystery!" said Brian Crawford, the veteran New York Road Runners Club adminstrator whose title was "race coordinator" in 1976. "It's one of the great mysteries of all time. And no one wants to take credit for it!"
  Spitz, then working as state auditor, confirmed that he had gone to Percy Sutton, then Manhattan borough president, with the five-borough proposal. But Spitz humbly added that "Harry Murphy had thought of the idea years before. Harry is dead now; he was a runner who finished third in the Queens Marathon in 1948."
  In that '48 marathon, runners had started at Idlewild Airport (now JFK) on Queens' south shore and worked their way north to the World's Fair grounds in Flushing Meadows.
  Anyway, Sutton, now chairman emeritus of Inner City Broadcasting, recalled that the five-borough brainstorm was appealing because "it would carry the race through every ethnic neighborhood, to every ethnic group in New York."
  Sutton saw it as a grand cultural parade, and even hoped to have vendors selling various ethnic foods at the finish line (a specific detail that never evolved). So Sutton brought the five-borough proposal to then- mayor Abe Beame, confident that Beame would go along "because Abe was a good guy."
  Corbitt said that one possible route, from the start on the Staten Island side of the Verrazano Bridge, placed the finish in the Columbus Circle area on the southwest corner of Central Park; the other at the United Nations on Midtown's east side. Eventually, a Central Park finish, near the Tavern on the Green Restaurant, was picked. There were early plans to run into Manhattan on the Triboro Bridge, before settling on the 59th Street Bridge.
  With the perfect hindsight of 20 years, Beame, who said that "the nearest I came to running a marathon was on the 100-pound relay [sic] team at the High School of Commerce," benignly praised Sutton and Jack Rudin, a civic booster from the city's most notable family real estate business and said, "I just thought it would be a nice thing for New York City."
  "We didn't know all the things it would require." Sutton said. "Police, sanitation and so forth. But I'd never seen any organizational structure work so well."
  To which Allan Steinfeld, then Lebow's right-hand man and now successor to the late Lebow as marathon director, responded, "There wasn't any structure."
  "But it looked good," Sutton said.
  Rudin's family happily put up $25,000 in sponsorship money in exchange for naming the marathon's championship trophy after his father. "Fred, to his credit, said from Day One, 'It'll never work,'" Rudin said. So, why did Rudin think it would work?
  "If these guys [who presented the initial plans] thought it would work, it would work. You know, it was presented as a one-shot thing, as part of the Bicentennial Celebration."
  In fact, banners that day advertised the '76 event as the "N.Y.C. Bicentennial Five-Borough Marathon." It was assumed that the marathon would go back to the friendly confines of Central Park in '77. Instead, details were tweaked to make it better, for one thing, the lonely stretch along the FDR Drive was replaced with what is now an annual hightlight. the tumultous spectator corridor along First Avenue.
  "Quite honestly," said the garrulous Crawford, "we never thought it would work. We thought it would be a royal screw-up. A one- shot deal, and 'Im-leavin'-town-after-the-marathon.'"
  Charlie McCabe, vice president of Manufacturers Hanover Bank (since merged with Chemical and then Chase), was approached by Lebow for $7,500 in sponsorship money. "We gave him $5,000," McCabe said. But McCahc also allowed Lebow and his marathon organizers to use a Manny-Hanny office for operations headquarters.
  Also in the mix then were Lynn Blackstone, who was in charge of getting world-class runners to compete. George Hirsch, then publisher of New Times magazine, who provided a slick program for the race; Joe Kleinerman, longtime racing official who handled runner applications and correspondence; Alice Schneider, now married to Steinfeld, a veteran volunteer stuffer of marathon envelopes.
  Mad scientists all. And their friendly monster still grows.


The Progressive, Pro-Peace choice in the New York City Democratic Primary for City Council 5th District on Manhattan’s Upper East Side and Roosevelt Island.